Fundraising isn't the only thing Magnolia Springs Public Library (MSPL) has done over the years. Back in 2019, MSPL volunteer Alida Given helped bring the 2018 Southern Exposure Film collection to Baldwin County's libraries, promoting awareness of environmental issues in Alabama. Records also indicate that back in 2013, Magnolia Springs was the first library in the state of Alabama to begin the Seed Lending Library program. This photo originally published with Gulf Coast Media in August 2019.

GCM File Photo

F. Scott Fitzgerald, renowned for his profound depiction of the human condition in classics such as "The Great Gatsby," once said, "That is part of the beauty of all literature. You discover that your longings are universal longings, that you’re not lonely and isolated from anyone. You belong."

For numerous individuals, the library serves as a sanctuary for books, events and social gatherings—an embodiment of the sense of belonging Fitzgerald spoke of. However, what occurs when this cherished haven is no longer available?

Unfortunately, that is the question Magnolia Springs residents may be asking themselves soon.

An Uncertain Future

Gulf Coast Media reported last week that the future of the Magnolia Springs Public Library (MSPL) is uncertain as the Magnolia Springs Library Board recommended its closure. The recommendation, brought up at the Feb. 27 Magnolia Springs Town Council meeting, cited fiscal responsibility, low usage rates and uncertainty surrounding local and state-level library councils.

Interim measures, such as utilizing the Bookmobile and directing patrons to nearby libraries, have been suggested to address immediate needs during the transition period.

While the Library Board envisions a possible reopening with a revamped structure, pending reforms within the Alabama State Library Council and the Baldwin County Library Cooperative, the proposed closure has stirred controversy among residents, who fear the loss of community programs and services, particularly for elderly and young patrons.

Community Response

Currently, the MSPL is temporarily closed. The decision on the library’s future is to be discussed on March 26. With the possibility of the MSPL closing, Gulf Coast Media reached out to residents of Magnolia Springs on Facebook to get their thoughts on the matter.

Most comments were not in favor of the closure. The comments expressed sadness and disappointment at the closure of the Magnolia Springs Library. Many commenters shared nostalgic memories of the library's role as a vital resource for homeschooling children, families and the community at large.

"We home school and would go weekly to check out books," Jenelle Schubert Moyer commented. "I hate that it has closed."

Commenters recalled the library's diverse offerings, from educational programs to social gatherings, and lamented its potential loss. Criticism was directed towards the decision-makers, with concerns raised about the impact on the community and the fear that the library may never reopen.

"I think the loss of the library is tragic," Jack Grace commented. "In some ways, the library was the social center of town. I think that is true of a lot of small towns. Some folks view the library as an anachronism because they think the library is only about books and they think no one bothers to read anymore. a local library is so much more. The Magnolia Springs library was a victim of an administration that did not want it and so a lot of instability ensued. It is a shame. We miss the library and now make the trek to the Foley library."

Despite the acknowledgment of alternative services like the Bookmobile, doubts lingered about accessibility. Overall, the comments highlighted the deep-rooted value of the Magnolia Springs Library as a cherished institution within the community.

"I love the library and am sad to hear of its closing," Darlene Webb commented. "My mother was an avid reader and the folks from the library made sure she had all the special books she wanted in her last months alive. We were so impressed with the kindness that in lieu of flowers we requested donations be made to the library in her name of which many were. You only get that type of service with a local library."

Funding Woes

In May 2006, residents of Magnolia Springs voted 224–96 in favor of incorporation, a milestone the town commemorates annually on June 29. With the town's establishment, discussions emerged regarding the initiation of a library. Despite initial reluctance from the council, the then-mayor advocated for its establishment. Through a substantial grant from the Snook Foundation, the Magnolia Springs Public Library was inaugurated in October 2011.

One commenter reached out via email to share their thoughts, but asked to remain anonymous. According to this source, individuals who support keeping the library open are likely to express their opinions in a public forum like Facebook. Conversely, those who advocate for closing the library may refrain from openly sharing their views due to feeling intimidated by outspoken individuals.

"The library has caused much discontent and grief since it's very early years," the person said. "Each year brought requests for more and more funding, a request that put extreme strains on a small-time budget. The Town was funding the library but was not a resource used by Magnolia Springs citizens. A large majority of users were from outside of our town."

The anonymous commenter went on to say that over the years, the library went through numerous librarians with only one or two providing services that benefited the community. Furthermore, the source stated that the library has been a political "hot potato" since its earliest years.

Reviewing the information on the Town of Magnolia Springs' website indicates a persistent challenge regarding funding for the library. Throughout its existence, the library has relied on financial support from the Town of Magnolia Springs, the Friends of the Magnolia Springs Public Library, as well as contributions from donations, sponsors and fundraising efforts.

A History of Commitment

Despite problems with funding, past reports from Gulf Coast Media indicate a longstanding community commitment to supporting the library. According to a report by Gulf Coast Media in 2017, Piggly Wiggly was once a sponsor of the MSPL. Though not extensive, other instances of community-related funding include United Bank's 2017 donation, the 2019 budget allocation due to the library's success, a $5,000 grant from the Alabama Humanities Foundation in 2020, and an anonymous donor's fundraising initiative involving a loquat tree adorned with beads in 2021. Additionally, in 2022, Harold Sherman's family-owned business offered a $10,000 donation, addressing the Town Council's struggle to extend library hours.

It should also be noted that many volunteers, inclduing child volunteers, have helped run the library over the year as well. These actions highlight ongoing efforts to sustain the Magnolia Springs Public Library despite funding uncertainties.

More Than Books

For many, the library isn't just a place for books; it's a sanctuary of knowledge and opportunity. Author Ray Bradbury once said, "Libraries raised me. I believe in libraries because most students don’t have any money...I couldn’t go to college, so I went to the library three days a week for ten years."

Throughout the years, the library has hosted many events, programs, classes, and more for the community. According to reports by the Press-Register and the library itself, Magnolia Springs was the first library in the state of Alabama to begin the Seed Lending Library program back in 2013. MSPL has hosted organizations such as the Stray Love Foundation, a nonprofit animal rescue group. The library also has been the gathering spot for book clubs over the years, some even meeting after library hours. The library also hosts local groups such as the Knit-Wits, a local knitting group. Lee Mitchell, former executive director of the South Baldwin Literacy Council, would often bring students participating in the literacy council program to story time at the MSPL. The library also offers free wifi to the community, providing crucial internet access to individuals who may not have it otherwise

Tammy Mattox, a supporter of keeping the library open, reached out to Gulf Coast Media by email to share her thoughts.

"My girls and I were fortunate enough to happen upon Magnolia Springs Library when my youngest was just in second grade and a very reluctant reader," Mattox said. "The librarian was such a joy and befriended us all. Because of her, my youngest soon became a voracious reader. She couldn’t wait to go to the library. She’s now in her second year at university and is thriving."

Mattox expressed gratitude for the MSPL, stating that all three of her daughters became volunteers at the library. She said her girls were actively involved in various tasks, such as preparing newsletters, providing technology tutoring and assisting the librarian with programs. Mattox emphasized the significant community connections forged at the library and individuals at the library who enriched Mattox and her daughters’ experiences with historical insights, children's literature and creativity.

Mattox also highlighted the library's role in aiding those in need, recounting instances where the librarian assisted patrons with job searches, resume printing and even providing support to children in a troubled family.

"Magnolia Springs Library was about so much more than books," Mattox said. "It was the hub of our community. It would be so disheartening for this to be the end of it."

What Lies Ahead

While the decision to close the library will not be decided until March 26, the community of Magnolia Springs holds a deep appreciation for its local library and hopes the library will remain open.

"The Magnolia Springs Library tied this little village together. It’s a meeting place for friends new and old. A place to find services," Sigrid Oaklief commented to Gulf Coast Media. "Please reconsider, we need the library."